Check the published context, the destination, and any referral activity you can observe. The evaluation depends on the placement’s purpose and what the available reporting can actually establish.
Before approving outreach, ask what the publisher would receive and why their audience would benefit. A useful contribution needs an editorial purpose beyond placing a link. The proposed destination should add something the reader can use rather than forcing a commercial page into an unrelated discussion.
What to ask the provider
Evidence: Maintain a record of the publication and its context. A list of domain names can hide whether references are visible, relevant, or still present. The review should include the actual page and any commercial conditions the business needs to understand. Ask how changes or removed references are handled without treating every lost link as a crisis.
Judgment: Do not accept a site metric as a substitute for judgment. A publisher can have an appealing score while the specific page is thin or disconnected from your audience. Conversely, a modest local organization may be relevant for reasons a general metric does not capture. The provider should explain the fit using observable details.
Follow-through: Referral reporting needs limits. Some placements may send visitors while others have no observable referral activity. A visit also does not establish that the person became a customer. Keep those distinctions visible and do not combine them into a claim about revenue the available evidence cannot support.
Ask what the provider will refuse. Bulk placement packages, unexplained ownership networks, and demands for prescribed commercial wording deserve scrutiny. The business should be comfortable with the public association, not merely reassured that a technical attribute makes the arrangement acceptable. Reputation remains part of the decision even when the proposal is labeled SEO.