A link does its work when a person who could hire you sees it. That means the page it sits on has to be about something related to your business, and it has to be read. A link from a page nobody visits is a line in a report, not an asset.
Ask to see the pages rather than a domain score. Read two or three of them and judge whether the site covers your trade or your area with any seriousness. Then look at where your link would sit: inside the article, next to a sentence that earns it, or buried in a list of related links at the bottom. Brad Johnson's relevance-first standard: topic fit and real traffic beat raw domain scores.
Before approving a list, open five of the pages and check the date on the last post. A site that has not published in a year is not a publisher, it is an inventory of old pages, and a link placed there tends to follow the page into obscurity. Those same five minutes reading the actual article tell you whether a link there would be seen by anyone who could hire you.





